A new (non-music) vessel from the Sombrero harbour · Launching Friday 30 October

Which is better, the book or the film?

Every episode, Ian Deeker Forth reviews a book, then co-host James Hillhouse reviews the film of the book. One novel, one adaptation, and the oldest argument in the cinema foyer: was the book better?

Now a Major Motion Podcast

How it works

Ian Deeker Forth, who reviews the book

First, the book

Ian Deeker Forth

Ian reads the novel and reviews it: the story, the writing, and whether it deserved a film at all. Ian also hosts Sombrero Fallout.

James Hillhouse, who reviews the film of the book

Then, the film

James Hillhouse

Co-host James watches the adaptation and reviews the film of the book: what made it to the screen, what got cut, and what Hollywood did to it.

Latest episodes

All episodes

  • Wuthering Heights: The Reviews

    Wuthering Heights: The Reviews

    Ian reviews Emily Bronte's Wuthering Heights novel: James reviews Emerald Fennell's ”Wuthering Heights” film. On the slate this episodeBook · 1846Wuthering HeightsEmily Brontë

Listen wherever you get your podcasts

New episodes land in your feed as soon as the credits roll. Subscribe and never miss an adaptation.